Here we go again! More talk about IPTV, Bandwidth, Content, and delivering it to you.
Astro TV conducting IPTV trials [link]
Essentially it boils down to this:
1. The pipe
- TM’s fiber optics (UniFi) has bucket-loads of bandwidth. Technically you can stream 3D HD streams, fast lag-less internet, voice and it’ll still have enough to cover
- Maxis / TimeDotCom have the basic fiber infrastructure, but it is only a small fraction of people covered.
- Streamyx. Technically it can hold up a 12 mbit connection, if the copper is good, and the DSL exchange is nearby. It covers huge parts of Malaysia, but is poorly maintained in some areas. So technically, Streamyx can stream HD interactive content as well!
- Wireless is pretty much limited. 3G networks, can’t really hold up in crowded areas with multiple heavy downloaders. It’s just catching up with the laws of physics. WE have to give 4G Wimax time to prove itself but we gotta keep in mind that there’s only so many bits that can be piped in a hertz of bandwidth!
- The landing points (Point of Presence) war is long lost to the likes of Singapore and Hong Kong. At it’s infancy, our government didn’t make the right plays to entice the big daddy Tier 1 internet providers (Level 3, Cogent, Teleglobe, NTT, etc). Hence today we have to lay fiber to Hong Kong or Singapore or Japan just to hook up to the US. Which, btw holds a huge chunk of our traffic needs.
2. The Content
- Astro wins hands down
- However, BitTorrent wins super double hands down if you wanna be a pirate, and copyright violator! I mean, with any internet connection, you can suck an episode of Top Gear (*not that I recommend doing), which is 700 MB, in
2 hours on Streamyx 1 mbit
30 minutes on Streamyx 4 mbit
25 minutes on Unifi 5 mbit
~ 2 hours on Digi 3G / Maxis 3G via your PHONE!
What pirates do is to line up their downloads, wait overnight and you’ll have a cache of movies and programmes to watch! From all over the world, uncensored, no commercials, and almost free!
3. The Cost
I’m not surprised that Astro has the guts and balls to charge people RM 20 extra for HD services (so few channels) on top of your regular subscription (avg. RM 100/mth) After all, they’re the only real player here. Rain fade? Who cares? What alternatives have you got?
In America, basic cable has at least 200 channels for a basic fee. An extra box for a second TV costs an extra $5. The vast range of HD programming is more competitively priced, certainly not such a premium.
Here in Malaysia, the 2nd box costs half your subscription! So if you have a RM 100 package, the 2nd box is RM 50!! Seems little, but over 3-5 years you are overpaying close to RM 1000!
As mentioned, BitTorrent is free. Get an ISP that don’t throttle your bandwidth (sadly, it’s Telekom because of their big network) and really really practice Net Neutrality (all bits are created equal, and should be treated equal!)
Conclusion
1. Malaysia needs more investment to build larger pipes to more locations (japan, usa).
2. Content providers should host their servers in Malaysia. I dream of the day when my 700MB movie downloads in 2 minutes flat because it is locally hosted.
3. We gotta stay ahead of the game, ya’ll! Educate, educate, educate.
Here’s a good read from Daily Finance on Net Neutrality and other discussions:
An epic and escalating war is now taking place over the next era of broadband content delivery. Some skirmishes are playing out in the public eye, but others — perhaps the most critical — are far removed from it. In fact, very few people know that the highly controversial efforts by Google and Verizon to hammer out their own proposal for a broadband policy framework — news of which broke only last month — started nearly two years ago. The outcome of this ever-hotter war will have a profound impact on the way consumers access information well into the future.